Holy Kaw! All the topics that interest us

Colleges say farewell to classics, philosophy programs

Media_httpdldropboxco_eftce

You can call me elitist; you can call me privileged; you can call me detached. But this article troubles me. The New York Times reports that in the midst of a shrunken job market, students and their families are calling for more education that prepares graduates for jobs and internships. In response, some universities are eliminating programs such as American studies, classics, and philosophy and replacing them with more preprofessional majors such as “The English Major in the Workplace” and “just about anything prefixed with ‘bio,’” reports the Times.

As a recent graduate myself, I can sympathize with the real anxieties and actual challenges to securing a first job. But at the same time I feel strongly about the importance of developing one’s intellectual capacity outside of what the Times calls "careerism." Learning how to read critically and write clearly, for instance, enables us to be more responsible global citizens. Understanding philosophy and history deepens our sense of universal human fragility and limits hubris. Literature puts us in other people’s shoes and builds compassion (in fact, some medical schools have incorporated literature to nurture empathy and train better doctors). Focusing on education’s function as a mere means to a specific job could limit school's place in refining such essential human sensibilities—not to mention put us on the wrong track too early. How many students know what they want to do for the next 40 years at age 18 anyway?

My suggestion? Keep the core programs and pump up career services.

Read the full report from NYT.

Stay on top of the latest on colleges.


Comments (11)

Jan 03, 2010
Jo Ann Crouch said...
The author reported colleges and employers still want students to learn good communication skills including writing. For instance, an English major would also learn good resume writing and discuss job related ideas in relevant literature.

Perhaps they don't connect learning empathy from core courses well enough, I agree, but I like that careers become part of the discussion throughout the curriculum.

Jan 03, 2010
timgier said...
I think that if colleges & universities are dropping philosophy & the classics, they've got it exactly backwards. People need to learn How To Think before they need any career specific skill set.
Jan 03, 2010
Tom said...
I was a science major and have made a career in applied science and product development, yet my career path would not have been possible without my philosophy minor and strong background in history and English (Lit and Writing). Half of success is in communicating, and that means being able to relate to others through storytelling. Universities that eschew solid education for "career" courses are badly out of touch with the workplace and doing a disservice to students and hiring managers.
Jan 03, 2010
Patrick Murdock liked this post.
Jan 03, 2010
Deborah Esch said...
As the article in the Times notes, universities and colleges have been doing this sort of curriculum revision at intervals for a long while. But the pace of the cuts seems to be accelerating, and the language of the justifications is to some extent new. Thanks for a thoughtful post.
Jan 03, 2010
Rufus Dogg said...
Wow! What happened to getting an education in college? If you want "job training" go to a technical school. No wonder we are getting dumber and dumber with no sense of history and how human beings are connected to each other..

What the hell will you ever use an English degree for? http://gerardmclean.com/what-the-hell-will-you-ever-use-an-english-degree-for.html

Jan 03, 2010
pquodling said...
Hmm, and with my son getting a Kindle for Xmas, he has been downloading and reading lots of the classics.
Jan 03, 2010
wilsonalext said...
You make an excellent point, education can not just be about being taught to do something. Without those 'classics' it becomes virtually impossible to understand the nature of something. And it is that very understanding that leads to the adaptability in a changing market. This process as a solution seems very short sighted.
Jan 03, 2010
Ken Jones PhD said...
Unfortunately, when revenue is the driver in a market economy, universities are just businesses. Courses are just revenue sources. Education is just job skills. Life is just getting by. Pity.
Jan 04, 2010
Deborah Esch said...

I highly recommend The University in Ruins, by Bill Readings, which puts all of this in the broader context of the history of the university.<o:p></o:p>

Jan 25, 2011
Joe Mangum said...
In a market like this, the last thing we need is more drones who only specialize in one specific area and lack the ability to think outside the box. A quality education is one that is well rounded and propels the mind to THINK. It's these types of people that CREATE hundreds of jobs as opposed to filling a position at one job.

Leave a comment...