Holy Kaw! All the topics that interest us

When is Comic Sans ok to use?

All the best bizarre, odd and funny news and all the best typography news.


Short answer: never.

By Annie Colbert.


Comments (29)

Oct 19, 2009
Catherine Faas said...
This is hilarious.
Oct 19, 2009
Natalie Nichols said...
Love this.. ;)
Oct 19, 2009
parlory said...
Very nice, Annie. I'd love to hear your thoughts on Bank Gothic.
Oct 19, 2009
Trudy said...
rotflmao
Oct 19, 2009
Tom Mahoney said...
Well gee - Comic Sans is part of our branding. Business cards, letterhead, some of it (not a lot) on the web site.

So OK - I'll bite - why shouldn't I use it????

Oct 19, 2009
Anna Johnson said...
I stumbled upon this, and my first impression clicking on it, I was thinking "Never!" Turns out I was right. lol I wish I could send that typeface warping into an oblivion with how many people abuse it. It's like showing up to a tux event in a clown suit.
Oct 19, 2009
Joy said...
Tom, if you have to ask why you should not use it then it's time to hire a professional graphic design artist.
Oct 20, 2009
jcukier said...
I'd respectfully disagree. The font was created for a purpose, which it served well. As a widely-distributed novelty font, it has certainly been overused, but more often than not it was the most efficient way for non-designers to infuse some humanity in digitally printed text.

I wouldn't use comic sans in an annual report. But then again, I wouldn't use verdana, tahoma or georgia either.

Oct 20, 2009
David Reinhardt said...
I found a link about the creator of Comic Sans the other day and tweeted it, even he recognised the error of his ways :-)

http://twitter.com/davereinhardt/status/4911145350

Oct 20, 2009
I use Comic Sans when I write a love letter! it's kind of personal, and better than the world's worst font Times New Roman
Oct 20, 2009
Tom Mahoney said...
In my defense (I hope) Comic Sans has worked well for our use. We are noted for being outside the box and wanted a light-hearted, very informal feeling to our brand. It does that without being too in-your-face ridiculous. Would I use it in the body of a letter or the default font on our site - no. But it does give the image we want on the business card, letterhead, store front sign and brochures.
Oct 20, 2009
james said...
I hate Comic Sans with a passion. It should be wiped from the face of the earth!
Oct 20, 2009
Vlad Georgescu said...
Tom. Stop using Comic Sans. Please.
Oct 20, 2009
Carl Hansell said...
Very good :)

@Tom.

Hi Tom, I would just like to help with a few good reasons designers would not kindly use this typeface.

The first and most obvious reason I think is its aesthetic value, many from a professional creative background would consider this a pretty ugly font if i'm honest. It is considered ugly not only in its appearance and lack of rhythm, but on an emotional level also. This may sound pretty arty-farty but it has no soul! It all really boils down to the emotions you wish your target audience to feel when they interact with your brand and how the typeface compliments your other fonts, images and general layout design on all your pages.

When many of us think of Comic Sans we feel/think:

1. Not very nice looking
2. Out of date
3. This isn't helping!
3. Doesn't sit well with any other typefaces
4. 'Office noticeboard' (someones trying to be light about it but its definitely, definitely a rule ;)

Obviously these are my own personal views as designer, if this seems to be working just fine for you thats great too!

Thoughts:

The kind of fun element you are going for with your type doesn't really seem to be consistent with the service you are offering. If your brand edges on the kookie there are many other great typefaces out there, they just don't come with mircosoft word. Have you thought about different colours? Maybe these could be the 'comic' side to your company? The logo? ... there are an array of design aesthetics to consider when you inevitably come to update your brands image. I'm currently updateing mine as it goes! :)

Oct 20, 2009
Tom Mahoney said...
I appreciate the input.  Will consider it if we ever re-brand, but it does work well for us and the branding was done by a designer, albeit six years ago. Changing it would be no small project, what with over 150 different product labels, store-front signs, and all the rest.

At 6:18 AM -0700 10/20/09,  Comment to Posterous typed out:
<x-tab>        </x-tab>--- Reply above this line to comment on this post ---<x-tab>   </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>Carl Hansell just commented on the post<x-tab> </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>"When is Comic Sans ok to use?" on<x-tab>      </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>Holy Kaw!<x-tab>       </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
Very good :)
@Tom.
Hi Tom, I would just like to help with a few good reasons designers would not kindly use this typeface.
The first and most obvious reason I think is its aesthetic value, many from a professional creative background would consider this a pretty ugly font if i'm honest. It is considered ugly not only in its appearance and lack of rhythm, but on an emotional level also. This may sound pretty arty-farty but it has no soul! It all really boils down to the emotions you wish your target audience to feel when they interact with your brand and how the typeface compliments your other fonts, images and general layout design on all your pages.
When many of us think of Comic Sans we feel/think:
1. Not very nice looking
2. Out of date
3. This isn't helping!
3. Doesn't sit well with any other typefaces
4. 'Office noticeboard' (someones trying to be light about it but its definitely, definitely a rule ;)
Obviously these are my own personal views as designer, if this seems to be working just fine for you thats great too!
Thoughts:
The kind of fun element you are going for with your type doesn't really seem to be consistent with the service you are offering. If your brand edges on the kookie there are many other great typefaces out there, they just don't come with mircosoft word. Have you thought about different colours? Maybe these could be the 'comic' side to your company? The logo? ... there are an array of design aesthetics to consider when you inevitably come to update your brands image. I'm currently updateing mine as it goes! :)
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
Posterous is the place to post everything. Just email us.<x-tab>       </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
Unsubscribe from this comment thread »
<x-tab>        </x-tab><x-tab>        </x-tab>
<x-tab>        </x-tab>


<x-sigsep>
-- 
</x-sigsep>

Tom Mahoney, Partner
The Barking Lamb
49 N Broad St.
Lititz, Pa  17543
717-627-1077
www.thebarkinglamb.com
Oct 20, 2009
Carl Hansell said...
@ Tom

Hey, no problem.

I totally understand. Re-branding is a bold step! but done correctly a great way to refresh a companies image and bring in new business at the same time. Most people would agree that after a rebrand they wouldn't go back given the choice. Congrats, six years is some good company growth. It would be nice to see your design reflecting you better still...

Oct 20, 2009
Monica said...
Parei de usar Comic Sans depois que meu irmão disse que é conhecido como fonte para usar em convite de festa de aniversário para crianças... É muito infantil mesmo...
Oct 20, 2009
Aaina Sharma said...
lol...I was gonna say it's NEVER ok to use it. Good one!
Oct 20, 2009
Tom Mahoney said...
I do have one other argument in favor of it - probably more compelling than any of the good arguments against it.

My wife likes it.

NOOOOOO - not even gonna suggest changing it.

Oct 20, 2009
Jordan Foutz said...
Comic sans when used in any context other than a kid's birthday invitation for a party that took place in 1995 makes me cringe. It is super ameteurish. Delete!
Oct 20, 2009
radmoose said...
When is it OK to use Comic Sans? Never? I disagree. When you are using it for captions in a comic =)
Oct 20, 2009
wheels said...
Wow! I created this because of a potential disaster in our office. I can't believe it got passed around the internet so quickly.
Oct 20, 2009
Tom Mahoney said...
Amazing. We have branding that is super ameteurish, belongs in a comic book, out of date, not very nice looking, and ugly at an emotional level. And still my business grows while others fall. Go figger.

I'm so lucky to have all these design snobby gurus reinventing what seems to work for me. At least you haven't given me a sales pitch ;-)

Oct 20, 2009
Andy said...
Hilarious. The only thing that would make it funnier were if it were written in Comic Sans...
Oct 20, 2009
catechase said...
This is TOO funny! People don't realize how much of an effect font can have in graphic design. I really want to do a blog post about terrible fonts used in apartment marketing, so if anyone has some examples there is contact information at http://nomorehomemadeflyers.com/
Oct 20, 2009
Wes said...
Very simply laid out :-), but I think it has use and value even for public viewing. However need to use it wisely and with good judgement!
Nov 05, 2009
Doug Stewart said...
Lol yeah...

But I'd use it. If someone wanted me to make a comic I'd consider it. Or a book for kids, I'd considering using it.

Basically, anything it was originally meant to be used for, I'd consider using it.

Nov 06, 2009
Web Design Kent said...
Brilliant, its amazing how many logos I come across designed with comic sans
Nov 06, 2009
Mishy said...
Ha! Fantastic :D

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    twitter