Why Facebook is good and Twitter is bad for your brain
Knock me over with a small feather: a psychologist named Dr. Tracy Alloway from the University of Stirling in Scotland believes that using Facebook can improve one's "working memory" and that using Twitter diminishes it. I haven't read her study so I don't know what it really says, but here's news coverage of it:
"Working memory" is the ability to remember information and to also use it. The theory is that Facebook forces you to keep up with friends and remember what they are doing. By contrast, Twitter involves short bursts of information that does not require extensive processing. All I can say is that Dr. Alloway should follow me on Twitter. She'd have plenty to process and would be amazed at the amount of thinking that goes into, and is required by, my tweets. :-)
The good (or bad) news that is that playing video games that involving planning and strategy may help the development of information processing. This is why I insist that my sons play Halo. And, believe it or not, there's a lot of team-play strategies that a game like Halo requires.
Comments (21)
Oh crap, what was I doing here again? I came from twitter.
http://bit.ly/3limLm
In an age where emotional intelligence is prevalent knowledge, we really should stop with these catch-all phrases of intelligence.
Similarly, working memory? Working memory on what? Neither twitter nor facebook nor videogames seem like they can produce any valuable memory even if you can remember them.
I'm not dissing them but I might as well say constantly letting yourself be nearly slashed to death, submitted until you tap, punched until you have enough feel for what a KO feels like and the constant daily trauma of life (as long as you don't try to shut it out) are even better for memory.
Somehow Facebook just seems slow and obsessed with more navel gazing - perfect for keeping up with personal friends.
Twitter is fast and (more often than not) leads you on interesting journeys all over the net. So my vote on working memory, whatever that is, goes for Twitter!
Another reason why I shud buy PS3! (not xbox)
Not trying to defend the researcher but there is some validity to that.
The video format + the time and content of Youtube is equivalent to the 140 characters style of Twitter.
Youtube just seems longer because of the video format but most of them have the same theme except the visual format of Youtube also allows for ads, TV recordings, etc. but videoblogging can be very similar with micro-blogging IMO.
Leave a comment...